doug — off the record

just a place to share some thoughts


Where Collaboration Goes to Die

Over the weekend, I was looking to enhance and expand my knowledge on a particular topic and my searching lead me to a wiki created to share the resource.  Great, I thought.  I’ve got some content to offer already and I’d be happy to exchange it and help grow the wiki.

But, I couldn’t.  The wiki was “locked’.

What the heck?

I’m starting to run into more of this in the research that I’m doing recently.  I recall a comment that went by earlier this summer “PDFs are where ideas go to die”.  PDF is a format that basically sends the message that the topic is done, over, kaput, finished, and the author has had the last say.

A locked wiki sends the same, or even harsher, message.  At least when you know that you’re going to look at a PDF document, you know what you’re getting.  By definition, a wiki is a collaboration space where the topic or resource gets better because of the collaboration of others.  When I go to visit a wiki that’s publically available, it is with the expectation that I’m going to be the benefactor of the collective knowledge of many folks.

But, what about people defacing or providing inaccurate content?  The power of the wiki is its ability to let the owner or management team know when something has changed.  Another powerful feature is the ability to roll back the wiki to a previous version should something go awry.

If you’re interested in locking down content, why not pretty it up and turn it into a webpage?  There are plenty of free places to post static content if price is an issue.  If you’re going to use a wiki, I would encourage all to exploit the power of the wiki.  It only takes a couple of clicks…here’s what it looks like at my PBWiki settings.

If you’re using a wiki publically, you’re at the edge of something very powerful.  Invite the world to make your efforts better.  Don’t let collaboration die at your place!
Social Bookmarks:

Powered by ScribeFire.



2 responses to “Where Collaboration Goes to Die”

  1. Hmmm — agree yet disagree.

    Was it LOCKED that you could not even apply to join — or was it LOCKED but with an invitation??

    Also — why was it locked? Sometimes there might be a reason (perhaps not a good reason) but one to listen to, think on, and then judge.

    I have a wiki that is locked — actually I have a few. My reason for them being locked is two fold.

    1. I am gun shy. I have had wiki’s open and have had them totally trashed by outsiders. Content that has been added that is not reflective of myself (nor of my beliefs).
    And I readily admit it — I am paranoid.
    However, there is an invite on the wiki — and if I know you — you are more than welcome to come in.

    2. I work with elementary age students. One protection I have promised parents is that the wiki is available for all to see — but only students and parents (at this time) can add content. For wary parents — this seems to help.

    One final note……. I think you will find it interesting that I had already bought the domain for one of my wikis — and will be moving it from the wiki format to a website — for exactly the reason that you stated.

    Thanks for sharing. I do look forward to other people’s additions to this conversation.
    Jen

    Like

  2. Thanks for dropping by and sharing, Jen. In this case, the wiki appeared to be totally abandoned with dated material, to be sure, but could merge with modern resources and be dynamite. There was no indication about how to join and edit. I take no issue with people who wish a little control over contents and applaud you for your carefulness.

    In the big scheme of things, I’m starting to see more and more dead rot. Someone takes a workshop on how to create a wiki or blog, make a single entry and then abandon it.

    I’m sorry to hear that you had resources trashed. That’s not right and speaks to the need for digital citizenship and responsibility. I like the idea of you moving your resources to a more appropriate platform and hope that you’ll share it with us.

    But let’s find a way to make wikis what they’re best designed for – collaboration areas where the results are bigger and better than any one of us.

    Like

Please share your thoughts here. I’d enjoy reading them.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.