doug — off the record

just a place to share some thoughts


Weekend research

Wasn’t that the weekend to end all weekends? It seemed like coverage from Ottawa was on every channel as we channel surfed. I even watched the Parliamentary Channel this morning to see the ongoing debate.

As an aside, it was interesting that not everyone who was debating was in the House. They had indeed pivoted and were coming in through whatever conferencing system they use. So, I stand by my comments on Saturday’s post.

There was a comment from one of the Members of Parliament, when questioned, indicating that he had not read the Emergencies Act but that he was speaking for the people in his riding. That floored me. I was curious to see where our local MP stood on this and there’s not a single reference on his website or Facebook page.

Now, I’m not a Member of Parliament but I’m guessing that I know how our MP will vote later tonight as it’s apparent that voting is going to come along party lines. I hope that some of the others have indeed read the Act.

So, while I won’t be voting, I’ll admit to doing a bit of research over the weekend to kind of get an idea of all that was making news.

That Area of Ottawa
I’ve never lived in Ottawa but I do have a relative who does and we visit periodically. We’ve had the tour of the Parliament area, dined in restaurants, and visited a couple of museums and they are all magnificent but I’ll confess that I know nothing about the street names, where they are, and where the intersections are. I’d still get lost in the city but I know now where Wellington St., Queen St., and Sparks St. are. Google Maps was good about indicating where the streets were closed and where slowdowns where. A really good resource was to go to Bing Maps where the traffic option showed the location of street cameras broadcasting live images.

Like the downtown in any big city, I was blown away by the number of restaurants and stores that were in the area and had all been closed because of the protest. I truly hope this kicks into gear: Ottawa police tell downtown businesses they can reopen after protesters clear out

Real news
On a regular day, newspapers, editorials, and television/radio report on a number of stories and the lead story is chosen for display. It’s very seldom that they report on the same story. This past while has been unique in that they’re all reporting on the same content and it’s their lead story. It’s a real opportunity to compare the sources head to head to see where they editorial direction is. If the service allows for public commenting, you’ll get a chance to see what their followers are like. Are they all real people?

Fake news
I can’t take any claim for this but it appeared as the lead story in one of the Best of Ontario Educators summaries. Fox News Contributor Admits to Creating Fake Story About Canadian Woman Being ‘Trampled’ to Death As noted in the story, it was fact checked and the original Twitter message withdrawn after the truth that the lady didn’t die was revealed. There’s a great deal of opportunity for media literacy and understanding the the United States is watching us. The problem is that you can’t unring a bell. Even today, there are still people sharing this misinformation.

Fact checking by CNN.

Social media
If you’re connected to the world with social media, check out what’s trending and what the top stories are. It’s a quick way to see what is happening and how things are being interpreted by others. Some are positive, some are negative, some are clearly (at least to me) just nonsense.

Not applicable laws
Now, I’ve watched enough Law and Order to know about Miranda Rights and the First Amendment to the Constitution. Yes, there were some people and American pundits claiming that these rights had been violated. That knowledge will serve them well when they visit the United States. In the meantime, it’s worth while doing a bit of research to see how it plays out in Canada.

Emergencies Act
Finally, there’s this whole Emergencies Act thing. It’s available online.
https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/e-4.5/index.html
It’s not a quick and easy read but it is manageable if you’re interested. It seems to me that it’s something that should be read if you’re going to be voting later tonight. Or, if you can’t or won’t take the time, surely your party has lawyers who live and breathe this stuff that can answer questions for you.

Sadly, I just know that this isn’t going to be the end of it. The talk, discussion, yelling, etc. will continue until the next election.



3 responses to “Weekend research”

  1. Good morning Doug!

    I remember years ago when I first learned how negative and adversarial the election campaigns in the US were, and appreciated how much more positive and mannered the Canadian politicians behaved. At some point, I became much more aware of how partisan the US was — It may have been Obama’s book lamenting how split the country was and how much more could be accomplished if the Democrats and the Republicans were better able to work together. It was as if Obama’s pleas fell on deaf ears, based on how the Republicans acted during his two terms as president. And then of course, things only became worse when Trump came on the scene.

    When Stephen Harper faced off against Trudeau in 2015, he really seemed to be grasping at straws when the Conservative ads showed him counting out money into someone else’s hand like some late night huckster showing someone how much they could save if they just ponied up and bought into his message. I found it quite sad to think that he and his handlers thought those ads would come across well. The ads seem to be borrowed right out of an American campaign handbook, and it concerned me that Canadian politics was being so negatively influenced by what seemed to be the norm down south.

    Fast forward seven years, and we are even more influenced by the fractured nature of our neighbour to the south, and the exporting of ideologies (and funding) northwords into the Canadian prairie states is really problematic. It really does seem as if the trucker convoy originated in Alberta, and Jason Kenny’s intention to challenge the emergency act really seems to be an effort on his part to continue the conservative/anti-mandate ideology that threw his province into a tailspin shortly after the “best summer ever” and salvage some brownie points with his base. The fact that the Emergency Act has its primary effect within Ottawa and Ontario should not cause the premier of Alberta any significant concern – – unless he is trying to shelter from consequences his Albertan protestors who headed into Ottawa to complain.

    I imagine that a good many Canadians are embarrassed by what has been seen coming out of Canada and portrayed on the world stage over the last three weeks. It looks like the country is up in arms and rebelling, and yet the reality is that it is only a tiny fraction of a percent that decided to have a hissy fit and camp out in the nation’s capital.

    What is one percent of 37 million?
    370,000.

    How many protesters dug in their heels and got themselves arrested? Maybe 200?
    If my orders of magnitude are correct, then that looks like 0.0005 of a percent.

    According to Statistics Canada (2019) there are 633,663 vehicles in Canada that weigh between 4500 kg and 14,989 kg — I am assuming that is the range into which tractor-trailers would fall. (The other category that Statistics Canada lists (vehicles weighing less than 4500 kg) would be cars and light trucks, and there are over 23 million of them!)

    Anyway, it appears that approximately 70 vehicles where towed/seized following the conclusion of the protest — that’s less than 0.00027 of a percent of all vehicles in Canada.

    How many protesters were there in downtown Ottawa during the occupation? Maybe 2000? (I don’t think I heard the number being that high, but let’s use that for easy math.) How much was the Ottawa police service spending per day to deal with the occupation (and this is before all of the additional police services were brought in to remove the protesters)? I think I heard the former chief of police reference $800,000 per day? So each protester was costing the city $400 per day? And that’s before you count up the money lost by the businesses in downtown Ottawa – – the federal government has indicated they are going to make up to $20 million available to help the businesses cope.

    It’s just terrible how such a small minority was able to hold the nation’s capital hostage (let’s not forget about the millions and millions of dollars in trade lost each day when the Ambassador bridge was closed, and the trade lost over the Alberta border due to the blockade there), and that that small minority seems to be driven to such extremes by unrealistic ideologies. As I said, it’s embarrassing, and not what I would expect from Canadian society.

    Like

Please share your thoughts here. I’d enjoy reading them.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.